Anne Perry's Christmas Mysteries

chapter Eight
A Christmas Secret

To all those who

would like to start again

CLARICE CORDE LEANED BACK IN HER SEAT AS the train pulled out of the station in a cloud of steam. Smuts flew and engine roared as they gathered speed on their journey northward. The rain beat against the window; she could barely see the glistening rooftops of London. It was December 14, 1890, ten days until Christmas Eve. She had been married little more than a year, and she was far from used to being a vicar's wife. Neither obedience nor tact came to her except with a considerable effort, but she made that effort for Dominic's sake.

She glanced sideways at him now and saw him deep in thought. She knew he was concerned about his ability to rise to this opportunity they had been offered so unexpectedly. The elderly Reverend Wynter had taken a richly deserved holiday; therefore his church, in the small village of Cottisham in Oxford-shire, needed someone to stand in for him and care for his flock over Christmas.

Dominic had seized the chance. He was a widower who had abandoned a self-indulgent life and embraced the ministry somewhat late. Perhaps no one but Clarice saw beyond his startlingly handsome face and charm of manner to the doubts beneath. She loved him the more fiercely because she knew he understood his own weaknesses as well as the power of his dreams.

He looked up and smiled at her. Once again she was warmed by amazement that he should have chosen her: the awkward sister, the one with the slightly crooked nose that gave her face a wry, individual look, the one with the tactless tongue and the pungent sense of humor, rather than any of the reliable and more conventional beauties eager for his attention.

This chance to go to Cottisham was the greatest Christmas gift they could have been given. It was an escape from serving under the Reverend Spindlewood in the bleak area of industrial London to which he had been sent as curate.

How could Clarice reassure him that they expected only patience, and that he should be there to listen and comfort, to assure them of the message of Christmas and peace on earth?

She reached her hand across and touched his arm, tightening her fingers for a moment. "It will be good," she said firmly. "And being in the country will be a delight."

He smiled at her, his dark eyes bright, knowing what she meant to tell him.

They traveled for nearly two hours, most of it through gently rolling countryside, the fields now bare except for the meadows still green. The woodlands and copses were without leaf, and the higher crowns of the hills were dusted with snow. Here in the heart of England winter could be surprisingly fierce, and no doubt there was far worse weather to come.

For the most part the villages lay in the hollows, the first sight from the train windows being the steep spires of the churches, then the huddled roofs.

They reached the station nearest to Cottisham and hired a pony trap to take them the last few miles through winding lanes, up the brow of a long, ridge-backed hill, and down into the sloping valley.

The village was beautiful, even though it boasted little more than a wide green with a duck pond and houses all around it. Many of the dwellings were thatched, their bare winter gardens neatly tidied. Perhaps half a dozen narrow roads twisted away into the surrounding woods and the fields beyond. The church was Saxon: slate-roofed, with a square tower rising high against the wind-torn clouds.

The pony trap drew up in front of the rambling stone vicarage. The driver unloaded their cases onto the gravel and quickly drove away.

Clarice looked at the closed door, then at the fine Georgian windows. It was a beautiful house, but it seemed oddly blind, as if it were oblivious to their arrival, and they would knock on the oak door in vain. This was to be their home, and Dominic's challenge and opportunity would be to preach and to minister without the supervision-or constant meddling-of the Reverend Spindlewood. Clarice knew she must behave with enthusiasm now, whatever doubt or loneliness she felt. That was what faith was about. Anyone can be cheerful when she is confident and the sun is shining.

She looked at Dominic once, then marched up to the front door and banged briskly with the lion's head knocker.

There was total silence from inside.

"Stay here with the boxes," Dominic said quietly. "I'll go to the nearest house. They must have left the keys with someone."

But before he could go more than a dozen steps a stout woman, her hair piled atop her head in an untidy knot, came bustling along the road. She struggled to hold a shawl around her shoulders against the wind.

"All right! All right! I'm coming," she called out. "No hurry! It ain't snowin' yet. You must be the Reverend Corde. An' Mrs. Corde, I take it?" She stopped in front of them and looked Clarice up and down dubiously, her blunt face skeptical. "I s'pose you know how to care for a house, an' all?" she said in a tone close to accusation. "I'm Mrs. Wellbeloved. I look after the vicar, but I can't do no more for you than a bit o' the heavy work, 'cos I've got family coming for Christmas, an' I need me holiday, too. In't good for a body to work all the days o' the year, an' it in't right to expect it."

"Of course we don't expect it," Clarice agreed, although she had in fact expected exactly that. "If you show me where to find everything and assist with the laundry, I'm sure that will be most satisfactory."

Mrs. Wellbeloved looked more or less mollified. She produced a large key from her pocket, unlocked the door, and led the way in. "Just leave them boxes. Old Will and young Tom'll bring 'em on up for yer."

Clarice followed her, pleasantly surprised by the warmth of the house, even though the vicar had been gone for a couple of days. It smelled of lavender, beeswax, and the faint, earthy perfume of chrysanthemums. Everything looked clean: the wooden floor, the hall table, the doors leading off to left and right, the stairs going up toward a wide landing. There was a large vase of branches and leaves of gold and bronze on the floor. For all her lack of grace, Mrs. Wellbeloved seemed to be an excellent housekeeper.

"You'll be liking it here," she said more to Dominic than to Clarice. It sounded something of an order. "Folks know how to behave decent. Come to church reg'lar and give to the poor. Won't be nothing for you to do but your duty. Just keep it right for the vicar to come back to. I'm sure he's left you a list of them as needs visiting, but if he hasn't, I can tell you." She opened the sitting room door to show them a graceful room with a wide fireplace and bay window, and then closed the door again. "You'll be takin' all services reg'lar," she went on, walking quickly toward the kitchen. "An' you won't be wantin' the sexton, but if you do, he's first on the right on the Glebe Road. Grave digger's two down beyond."

"Thank you, Mrs. Wellbeloved." Dominic avoided meeting Clarice's eyes and answered with as straight a face as he could manage.

"I'll be in reg'lar for the heavy stuff, 'ceptin' Christmas Day, an' Boxin' Day, o' course," Mrs. Wellbeloved continued. "You'll have enough coal an' coke an' likely enough kindlin', but if you haven't you can go walk in the woods an' pick up plenty. Works best of all, if you dry it proper first. An' you'll walk Harry, too. I can't be doin' that."

"Harry?" Dominic asked, puzzled.

"Harry." She looked at him witheringly. "The dog! Didn't the vicar tell you about Harry? Retriever, he is. Good as gold, if you treat him right. An' Etta. But you don't need to do nothin' for her, 'cept scraps and stuff, an' milk. She'll fend for herself."

Clarice made a quick guess. "Etta's a cat?"

Mrs. Wellbeloved looked appeased for their ignorance. "Right good little mouser, she is. Plain as you like, but clever. Capture 'em all in the end." She said it with satisfaction, as if she identified with the animal and were in some oblique way describing herself as well.

Clarice could not help being amused. "I am sure we shall get along excellently. Thank you for showing us in. We shall have a cup of tea, and then unpack."

"There's everything you'll need for today," Mrs. Wellbeloved said, nodding. "Game pie in the pantry, an' plenty o' vegetables, such as there is this time o' year. You'll need onions. Vicar loved 'em. Hot onion soup best thing in the world for a cold, he said. Smells worse 'n whiskey, but at least you're sober." She gave Dominic a hard, level look.

He returned it unflinchingly, then slowly smiled.

Mrs. Wellbeloved grunted. A pink blush spread up her face, and she turned away. "Handsome is as handsome does," she muttered under her breath.

Clarice thanked her again and saw her to the door. She was ready to be alone in her new temporary home and take stock of things. But first she wanted a cup of tea. It had been a long journey, and it was close to the shortest day in the year. Storm clouds were looming up over the trees, and the light was fading.

The house was everything she could have hoped. It had charm and individuality. The furniture was all well used, but also well cared for. Nothing really matched, as if each piece had been gathered as opportunity arose, and yet nothing appeared to be out of place. Oak, mahogany, and walnut jostled together, and age had mellowed them all. Elizabethan carving did not clash with Georgian simplicity. Everything seemed to be useful, except for one small table with barley-twist legs, which was apparently there simply because it was liked.

The pictures on the walls were also obviously personal choices: a watercolor of Bamburgh Castle on the Northumberland coast, rising out of the pale sands with the North Sea beyond; a Dutch scene of fishing boats; half a dozen pencil sketches of bare trees; more winter fields and trees in pen and ink. She found them remarkably restful; her eyes returned to them again and again. Upstairs she found another sketch, this time of the ruins of Rievaulx Abbey, bare columns and broken walls towering against the clouds.

"Look at this," she called to Dominic, who was carrying the last case up to the box room. "Isn't it lovely?"

He put the box away before coming to stand a little behind her, his arm around her shoulder. "Yes," he agreed, examining the picture carefully. "I like it very much." He peered at the signature. "It's his own! Did you see that?"

"His own?" she asked.

"The bishop told me he painted," he replied. "He didn't say how good he was, though. That has both power and grace to it. At least I think so. I'm looking forward to meeting him when he comes back."

She caught the edge of ruefulness in his voice. Those three weeks would go by too quickly, and then they would have to return to London, and the Reverend Spindlewood. Before that time he must somehow show that he was wise enough, gentle enough, and patient enough in listening to care for the village alone. He must be passionate and original in his sermons, not only to hold interest but also to feed the heart with the special message of Christmas. She knew this mattered to him intensely, and that his belief in himself wavered. Only the total upheaval of his life had made him consider religious faith at all.

Empty words of assurance from her would not help. He already knew she believed in him, and took it for granted that it was born of her love more than any realism.

"I wonder if he'll do any more drawing while he's away this time," she said aloud. "I don't even know where he's gone."

***

She awoke the next morning to stand shivering in her nightgown and drew open the curtains onto a glistening white world. The vicarage garden was surprisingly large and backed onto the woods. The trees were dusted with snow in wildly intricate patterns like heavy lace against a lead-gray sky, and the pale light gave it an eerie, luminous quality. She breathed out slowly in amazement at its beauty, momentarily forgetting to shiver.

She stared at the scene in rapture until suddenly she remembered there was housework to be done: grates to clean out, fires to be laid and lit, and breakfast to be cooked. And of course Harry and Etta to be fed. She could not afford to wait for Mrs. Wellbeloved to come.

A little after ten o'clock, when Dominic was in the study reading some of the vicar's notes and trying to familiarize himself with the parish, there was a noise outside in the gravel drive. Harry came trotting out of the kitchen, where he had been asleep by the stove. His nose was in the air and his plumed tail was waving; however, he did not bark.

Clarice snatched off her apron and went to open the door just as the knocker sounded. She pulled it wide to see a man standing just back from the step. He was a little above average height and apparently slender, although under the weight of his winter coat it was hard to tell. His face was fine-boned, not exactly handsome, but full of intelligence and a wry, sad wit. His complexion was deep olive, and his eyes had the liquid darkness that comes from the East. When he spoke, however, his voice was as English as her own.

"How do you do, Mrs. Corde. I am Peter Connaught." He gestured vaguely behind him. "From the manor house. I wanted to welcome you to the village." He held out his hand, then glanced at the smooth leather glove and apologized, pulling it off.

"How do you do, Mr. Connaught," she replied, smiling at him. "That is most kind of you. May I offer you a cup of tea? It's terribly cold this morning."

"That would be most welcome," he said with a nod. "I think it's going to be a hard Christmas-for weather, but I hope not for anything else."

She stepped back and opened the door wider for him. He came in, glancing around as if perhaps the vicarage might have changed since he had been there last. Then he relaxed and smiled again, reassured. Did he think they would have moved things in a night?

She took his coat and showed him into the sitting room, grateful she had lit the fire early and it was pleasantly warm. She noticed how again he looked around, smiling at familiar things, the pictures, the way the furniture was arranged, the worn chairs with their colors blending.

"If you will excuse me, I shall tell my husband you are here. Then I shall bring tea."

"Of course." He inclined his head, rubbing his hands together. His polished boots were wet from the snow. The wind had whipped color into his face.

She went to the study first and opened the door without knocking.

"Dominic, Mr. Connaught from the manor house is in the sitting room. I'm just going to bring tea. It's very good of him to come, isn't it!"

He looked a little surprised. "Yes. And very quick." There was a note of apprehension in his voice.

Clarice heard it and was afraid he was anxious already that she might be too frank in her opinions, too quick not only to see a better way of doing something but also to say so. It had been known to happen before.

"I suppose I should call upon his wife. She will know all the women in the village and everything about them. He didn't mention her," she added, biting her lip and looking straight into his eyes. "But I promise I shall behave perfectly. I will find her delightful and extremely competent, I swear. Even if she is a blithering idiot with a tongue like a dose of vinegar! I really do promise."

He stood up. "Just don't expect me to be there. I couldn't keep a straight face!" he warned, touching her cheek so lightly she barely felt it. "Don't change too much. I wouldn't care to be Archbishop of Canterbury if I had to lose the person you are in order to do it!"

"Oh, if you were Archbishop of Canterbury," she said cheerfully, "I would probably say whatever I pleased! Everyone would be far too in awe of you to criticize me."

He rolled his eyes and went out to meet their guest.

She went into the kitchen happily. To be loved for herself, with all her dreams and vulnerabilities, the mistakes and the virtues, was the highest prize in life, and she knew that.

When she returned with the tray of tea and biscuits, she found both men seated by the fire talking. They rose immediately. Dominic took the tray from her and set it down. They exchanged the usual pleasantries. She poured and passed Connaught his cup, then Dominic.

"Sir Peter has been telling me a little about the village," Dominic said, catching her eye. "His family has been here for centuries."

She felt herself blush. She had not known his title and had called him Mister when she had asked him in. She wondered if he was offended. Normally she would not have cared, but all this mattered so much. She was not impressed with people's ancestors, but this was not the time to say so. She composed her face into an expression of interest. "Really? How fortunate you are to have deep roots in such a lovely place."

"Yes," he agreed quickly. "It gives me a great sense of belonging. And like all privileges, it carries certain obligations. But I believe they are a pleasure also. I was very sad when I learned the Reverend Wynter was taking his holiday over Christmas, but now that we have you here, I am sure it will be as excellent as always. Christmas is a great time for healing rifts, forgiving mistakes, and welcoming wanderers home."

"How very well you express it," Dominic responded. "Is that what the Reverend Wynter has said in the past, or your own feeling?"

Sir Peter looked slightly surprised, even momentarily disconcerted. "My own. Why do you ask?"

"I thought it so well phrased, I might ask you if I could use it," Dominic replied candidly. "I would like to say something truly appropriate in my Watch Night sermon, which has to be as short as possible, yet still have meaning. But I cannot prepare it until I have at least a slight acquaintance with the village and the people."

Sir Peter leaned forward a little, a very slight crease between his dark brows. "Did the Reverend Wynter not tell you at least a little about us, collectively and individually?"

Watching him, Clarice had the sudden certainty that the answer mattered to him far more than he wished them to know. There was a tension in the lines of his body, and the knuckles of his beautiful hands were white on his lap.

Dominic appeared not to have noticed. "Unfortunately I never met him," he answered. "The request came to me through the bishop. I gather the Reverend Wynter's decision to take a holiday was made very quickly."

"I see." Sir Peter leaned back again and picked up his tea. "That is a trifle awkward for you. Whatever I can do I shall be more than happy to. Call upon me at any time. Perhaps you will dine with me at the hall one evening, when you are settled in?" He looked at Clarice. "I regret my hospitality will offer you no female company, since my mother has passed away, and I am not married, but I promise to show you much that is of interest if you care for history, art, or architecture. I can tell you stories of all manner of people good and evil, tragic and amusing, belonging to this village down the ages."

She did not have to pretend interest. "I think that would be infinitely more enjoyable than any feminine gossip I can imagine," she replied. "And I will most certainly come."

He looked pleased, as if the prospect excited him. Obviously he was enormously proud of his heritage and loved to share it, to entertain people, fill them with laughter and a little awe as well. He looked at Dominic. "I see you have moved the chessboard. You do not play?"

Dominic glanced around. He clearly had no idea where the chessboard had been.

"You didn't?" Sir Peter said quickly. "It was already gone when you came?"

"Yes. I haven't seen one." He looked at Clarice questioningly.

"I haven't seen it, either," she said. "Did the Reverend Wynter play?"

A look of pain burned deep in Sir Peter's eyes; with an effort he banished it. He swallowed the last of his tea. "Yes. Yes, at one time. He had a particularly beautiful set. Not black and white so much as black and gold. The black was ebony, and the gold that extraordinary shade that yew wood sometimes achieves, almost metallic. Quite beautiful. Still..." He rose to his feet. "It hardly matters. I just noticed because it was such a feature in the room. The light caught it, you know?"

"It sounds wonderful," Clarice responded, because the silence demanded it, but her mind was filled with the certainty that his reason for asking was nothing like as casual as he had said. There was a depth of emotion in him that could not be explained by the mere absence of an artifact of beauty. What more had it meant to him, and why did he conceal it?

She still wondered as she also rose to her feet and followed him to the door, thanking him again for his kindness in coming.

***

Mrs. Wellbeloved arrived after luncheon, carrying a large bag of potatoes, which she set down on the kitchen table with a grunt of relief. "You'll be needin' 'em," she said.

"Thank you," Clarice accepted, telling herself that Mrs. Wellbeloved meant it kindly and it would be most ungracious to tell her that she would rather have gone to the village shop and bought them herself. Three weeks was such a short time to get to know people so she could help Dominic. "Thank you," she repeated. "That was very thoughtful. We had a visitor this morning." She carried the potatoes into the scullery, followed hopefully by the dog, who was ever optimistic about something new to eat.

"Come down here, did he?" Mrs. Wellbeloved said, her round eyes wide with interest, wispy eyebrows high. "Well, I never." She picked up the long-handled broom and began to sweep the floor.

Clarice returned to the kitchen, Harry still on her heels.

"He said his family has been in the village for years," she added, tidying one of the cupboards and setting jams, pickles, savory jellies in some sort of order.

"Years!" Mrs. Wellbeloved exclaimed. "I should say centuries, more like. Since the Normans came, the way he tells it."

"The Normans! Really?"

"Yes. Ten sixty-six, you know?" Mrs. Wellbeloved looked at her skeptically. How could she be the lady she pretended if she did not know that?

Clarice was amazed. "That's terribly impressive!"

"Oh, he's impressed." Mrs. Wellbeloved bent awkwardly and picked up the modicum of dust from the floor, carefully pushing it into the dustpan. "Come over with William the Conqueror, so he said, an' bin in this village since the year twelve hundred. Everyone knows that." She made an expression of disdain then concealed it quickly, reaching for the bucket, putting it in the low, stone sink, and turning on the tap.

"He didn't tell me that." Clarice felt a need to defend him, although she had no idea why.

"Well, there's a surprise then." Mrs. Wellbeloved turned off the tap and heaved the bucket out. She looked at the floor skeptically. "Don't seem too bad."

"It isn't," Clarice replied. "We haven't been here a whole day yet. I really don't think you need to do it."

"P'raps you're right. I'll just do the table then. Got to keep the table clean." She took the scrubbing brush off its rack, along with a large box of yellow kitchen soap. "Knew his father, Sir Thomas. He was a real gentleman, poor man."

"Why? What happened to him?"

"Went abroad, he did." Mrs. Wellbeloved began scrubbing energetically, slopping water all over the place, wetting the entire surface of the table at once. "Foreign parts somewhere out east. Don't recall if he ever said where, exact. Fell in love and married." She poked loose strands of hair back into their knot. "Then she died, when Sir Peter was only about five or six years old. Wonderful woman, she was, from all he says, an' very beautiful. Sir Thomas were so cut up by it he came home and never went back there, ever. Raised Peter himself, teaching him all about his family, the land, all that. Very close, but never got over her death. I s'pose Sir Peter didn't, either. He never married."

"There's time yet," Clarice said quickly. "He looks no more than in his forties. He'll want to keep the line going, the family, surely?"

Mrs. Wellbeloved put her weight into the scrubbing, her lips tight, soapsuds flying. She stepped sideways and nearly fell over the dog. "It's his duty," she agreed. "But he isn't doing it, for all that. Maybe that's what it was all about."

"What what was all about?" Clarice asked unashamedly.

Anne Perry's books